 |
|
Home| About Us| Submit Manuscript| Search Archives| Contact Us |
|
Current Issue: Links for authors and reviewers:
|
1. Inappropriate or incomplete statistics 2. Overinterpretation of results 3. Inappropriate or suboptimal instrumentation 4. Too small sample size or biased sample 5. Text difficult to follow and understand 6. Insufficient or incomplete problem statement 7. Inadequate, incomplete, inaccurate, or outdated review of the literature 8. Insufficient data presented 9. Defective tables or figures
Top 9 Reasons for Acceptance of Manuscripts 1. Important, timely, relevant, critical, prevalent problem 2. Well-written manuscript (clear, straightforward, easy to follow, logical) 3. Well-designed study (appropriate, rigorous, comprehensive design) 4. Thoughtful, focused, up-to-date review of the literature 5. Sample size sufficiently large 6. Practical, useful implications 7. Interpretation took into account the limitations of the study 8. Problem well stated, formulated 9. Novel, unique approach to data analysis Bordage G. Reasons reviewers reject and accept manuscripts: the strengths and weaknesses in medical education reports. Academic Medicine 2001;76:889-896. |
Advertise|
Subscribe|
Feedback |